Weight gainBuying guide

The Best Shakers and Blenders for Weight-Gain Shakes

A shaker for powder and milk, a blender for homemade 900-calorie shakes.

Spinach, raspberries and cucumber in a blender jar

Quick picks

Photo of BlenderBottle Classic V2 Shaker (28 oz)Best shaker

BlenderBottle Classic V2 Shaker (28 oz)

Quick protein and gainer shakes

Check price on Amazon
Photo of nutribullet Pro 900Best blender

nutribullet Pro 900

Homemade high-calorie shakes

Check price on Amazon
Photo of PROMiXX Pro Electric ShakerBest electric shaker

PROMiXX Pro Electric Shaker

Gym bags and clumpy powders

Check price on Amazon

We earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Brands cannot pay for a place in our guides. How we make money.

How you make your shake decides what you need. Powder and milk? A shaker. Real food? A blender.

Our picks at a glance

How we picked, and why you can trust it

  • Capacity and power from makers’ specs.
  • Matched to how you make your shake.

We compare makers’ published specifications and labels, warranty and support, independent certification where it exists, and the problems that come up again and again in owner reviews. We earn a commission if you buy through our links; it never decides what we recommend. How we research.

The picks in detail

1Best shakerBudget

BlenderBottle Classic V2 Shaker (28 oz)

BlenderBottle

No lumps, cheap, dishwasher safe.

Capacity
28 oz (markings to 22 oz)
Material
BPA-free plastic, steel whisk
Dishwasher
Top rack
Measurements
Marked up to 22 oz

What we like

  • Cheap
  • No lumps
  • Easy to carry

What to know

  • Can’t blend food
  • Smells if left dirty
  • Lid seal wears

Skip it if: You blend fruit, oats or nut butter.

Read the full review →
2Best blenderBudget

nutribullet Pro 900

nutribullet

900 W and a 32 oz cup for big homemade shakes.

Power
900 W
Cups
32 oz and 24 oz (bundles vary)
Type
Personal blender
Model
NB9-1301

What we like

  • Big cup for gainer shakes
  • Handles oats and nut butter
  • Quick to clean

What to know

  • No speed control
  • Not for big batches
  • Loud

Skip it if: You only mix powder and milk; a shaker is enough.

Read the full review →
3Best electric shakerMid-range

PROMiXX Pro Electric Shaker

PROMiXX

A rechargeable mixer that smooths out clumpy gainer powder.

Capacity
20 oz (600 ml)
Power
USB-C rechargeable
Battery
USB-C rechargeable; 20+ mixes per charge (maker claim)
Supplement pod
About 130 ml (4.5 oz) clip-on compartment

What we like

  • Smooth shakes
  • Portable
  • Powder pod

What to know

  • Costs more than a plain shaker
  • Needs charging
  • Base is not dishwasher safe

Skip it if: You blend whole foods; get a blender.

Read the full review →
4Best budget blenderBudget

Ninja Fit Personal Blender (QB3001SS)

Ninja

700 W with two 16 oz to-go cups.

Power
700 W
Cup size
16 oz
Weight
3.1 lb
Model
QB3001SS

What we like

  • Cheap
  • Small footprint
  • Easy to clean

What to know

  • Small cups
  • One speed
  • Less power than NutriBullet Pro

Skip it if: You make big gainer shakes; pick the NutriBullet Pro 900.

Read the full review →
5Best insulatedMid-range

Ice Shaker 26 oz

Ice Shaker

Keeps a morning shake cold all day.

Capacity
26 oz
Insulation
Cold for 30+ hours, hot for about 12 (brand claim)
Material
Stainless steel
Size
About 3.25 × 9 in

What we like

  • Keeps shakes cold
  • No smell build-up like plastic
  • Quiet agitator

What to know

  • Heavier than plastic
  • Costs more
  • No measurement window

Skip it if: You only shake and drink straight away; a BlenderBottle is cheaper.

Read the full review →
6Best value blenderBudget

Ninja Nutri-Plus Personal Blender (BN301)

Ninja

900 peak watts with three 20 oz cups.

Power
900 peak watts
Cup size
20 oz (three cups)
In the box
Base, Pro Extractor blades, 3 cups, 2 spout lids, 1 storage lid
Warranty
1-year limited

What we like

  • Powerful for the price
  • Three cups
  • Easy to clean

What to know

  • 20 oz cups limit big shakes
  • Loud
  • Single speed

Skip it if: You want the largest cups; the NutriBullet Pro has 32 oz.

Read the full review →
7Cheapest blenderBudget

Magic Bullet Blender (11-Piece)

Magic Bullet

Fine for powder, milk and banana.

Power
250 W
Model
MBR-1101
In the box
Base, cross blade, tall cup, short cup, party mug, lip rings, lids, to-go lid, recipe guide

What we like

  • Very cheap
  • Tiny footprint
  • Lots of cups

What to know

  • Weak with ice
  • Loud
  • Small cups

Skip it if: You blend ice, oats or frozen fruit often; get the Ninja or NutriBullet.

Read the full review →

How to choose

Powder and milk

A shaker is all you need.

Oats, banana, nut butter

You need a blender with a big cup.

Frequently asked questions

Is a homemade gainer cheaper?

Often, yes. Milk, oats, banana, peanut butter and whey can reach 900 calories. See our recipe.

Before you buy: learn more

A note on health. This is general information, not medical or nutritional advice. If you have a health condition, are pregnant, take medication or have a history of disordered eating, talk to a doctor or registered dietitian before changing how you eat or exercise.

Keep reading